Strip Back the Paint

An excerpt from Chapter 10 of Stories That Sell™, the forthcoming book by Paul Johns.
Polish has become free.
Anyone who has renovated an old house knows the moment.
You start stripping back the paint, expecting to find wood underneath. And sometimes you do—beautiful, solid, worth restoring. But sometimes you find another layer of paint. And another. And under that, filler, covering a crack someone decided years ago was easier to hide than to fix.
Businesses accumulate paint in exactly the same way.
Every new leadership team adds a layer. Every rebrand adds a layer. Every product launch, every acquisition, every campaign, every new messaging framework. Each one goes on top of the last, and nobody ever goes back to see what is underneath.
After a few years, the story the business tells is thick, glossy and almost impossible to see through. And very often, nobody inside the business can say with confidence whether there is solid wood underneath it or not.
This chapter is about stripping it back.
The Symptoms of Too Much Paint
You can usually tell a business has too much paint by listening to how it describes itself.
The language gets bigger as the meaning gets smaller. Leading. Innovative. Best-in-class. End-to-end. Seamless. Transformational. Next-generation. Intelligent. AI-powered. Words that every competitor also uses, and which therefore tell the buyer precisely nothing.
The story gets longer as the clarity gets shorter. The website has forty pages and none of them answers the three questions. The pitch deck has sixty slides, of which the customer will remember two. The “elevator pitch” takes four floors and a change of lift.
And the versions multiply. Ask five people in the business to describe what it does, and you get five different answers—each of them plausible, none of them the same. Sales tells one story. Product tells another. The website tells a third. The chief executive tells a fourth to investors. Service, meanwhile, is quietly managing the gap between all of them.
That is word soup. Activity without accountability. Motion without momentum.
And it has a commercial cost, even if nobody puts it in the board pack. Every additional layer of complexity makes the story harder for your champion to retell, harder for your sellers to use and easier for a pretender to imitate.
Polish Is Not Proof
Polish has become free.
Anyone can now generate confident, fluent, beautifully structured marketing copy in seconds. Every pretender has a glossy website. Every start-up sounds like an industry leader.
That means polish no longer signals quality. In fact, in a market saturated with it, polish increasingly signals the opposite. Buyers have learned that the most impressive-sounding proposition is often the one with the least underneath it.
So the instinct to add another coat of paint—a sharper tagline, a bolder claim, a more sophisticated campaign—is usually the wrong one. It makes you look more like everybody else, not less.
What cuts through now is the opposite of polish. Specificity. Plain language. Evidence. A willingness to name what you don’t do. The texture of real experience.
The contender’s story should feel less like a brochure and more like a conversation with someone who genuinely knows what they’re talking about.
Back to Five Bullet Points
The tool I use most often for stripping back the paint is the one Alex taught me in Wokingham.
Five bullet points. One page.
It is deceptively simple, and most leadership teams find it surprisingly hard. When I ask them to describe their story in five points, the first attempt is almost always a list of products or capabilities. The second attempt is usually a list of values or aspirations. It is often the third or fourth attempt before we get to something that actually answers the questions a buyer is asking.
That struggle is the point. The exercise forces choices. It forces the team to decide what matters and what doesn’t—to let go of things they have worked hard on but which don’t move the story forward.
And it exposes the cracks. If a leadership team can’t agree on five points, the problem isn’t the messaging. It is the strategy. If you cannot explain your strategy in five clear points, you don’t have a strategy. You have a collection of thoughts.
Read more in Stories That Sell™
Stories That Sell™ is Paul Johns’ forthcoming book on how strategic storytelling creates competitive advantage, customer preference and enterprise value. It introduces the RO40 frameworks: Identity, the Three Question Test, the Message Map, Marketecture and Decision Confidence.
Want to put these ideas to work in your business? RO40’s Stories That Sell™ workshop brings your leadership, sales, marketing, product and customer teams together to build a story that sells. Start a conversation with RO40.



Comments