top of page

Contenders vs. Pretenders

Writer: Paul Johns
Paul Johns
3d
4 min read

An excerpt from Chapter 2 of Stories That Sell™, the forthcoming book by Paul Johns.

The pretender doesn’t have to beat you. It just has to make you look expensive.

Every market now has two kinds of competitor.

There are contenders: businesses with the depth, the delivery, the data and the trust to keep the promises they make.

And there are pretenders: businesses that can make the same promises, often more fluently, with very little underneath them.

The difficult thing is that, from the outside, they can look almost identical.

It used to be relatively easy to tell them apart. Building a credible software business took years. You needed engineers, infrastructure, implementation teams, a support function, references. Credibility had a cost of entry, and that cost acted as a filter. If a vendor made it onto your shortlist, they had at least survived long enough to be taken seriously.

That filter has gone.

Today, a pretender can arrive fully formed. A handsome website, written in minutes. A product demonstration that flows beautifully. Case studies that read like they were written by an experienced analyst, because in a sense they were. A pricing model that makes your proposal look heavy and old-fashioned. An AI assistant on the homepage that answers every question instantly and confidently.

Nothing about the surface tells the buyer what lies beneath it.

And buyers don’t start beneath the surface. They start with what they can see.

I want to be careful here, because there is a lazy version of this argument, and it is one I hear often in established businesses.

It goes like this: the new entrants are all smoke and mirrors. Their products are thin. Their AI hallucinates. Their customers will find out soon enough. We just need to wait.

Some of that may be true. But waiting is not a strategy, and contempt is not a defense.

Because the line between contender and pretender doesn’t run neatly between old and new. Some of the new entrants are genuine contenders—better architected, more focused, faster to value than the incumbents they are attacking. And some incumbents are, if they are honest with themselves, pretenders of a different kind: businesses still telling the story of the product they had five years ago, living off a reputation that their current offering no longer fully earns.

The question isn’t whether your competitors are pretending.

The question is whether you are.

The Optical Illusion

In Chapter 1, I described the optical illusion of competitiveness: a polished interface over a thin foundation, enough to get into the room, onto the shortlist and into the conversation you assumed was yours.

The reason this illusion is so powerful is that most buying processes are designed to evaluate appearances.

Think about how a typical evaluation runs. A long list is drawn up from searches, analyst reports and recommendations. Websites are reviewed. Demos are scheduled. A short list is formed. Proposals are compared. References are taken, usually from customers the vendor has chosen.

At almost every stage, what is being assessed is the presentation of capability, not the experience of it. The buyer sees the demo, not the data quality. They see the roadmap, not the delivery history. They hear the promise, not the service model.

The pretender has optimized for exactly those stages.

And because the pretender’s costs are lower—no legacy, no installed base to support, no decade of technical debt—they can usually undercut on price. They don’t have to win the deal to hurt you. They only have to appear credible enough to reset the buyer’s expectations. Suddenly your price looks inflated. Your implementation timeline looks slow. Your proposal, which was perfectly reasonable a year ago, starts to look like the thing the buyer has been warned about.

The pretender doesn’t have to beat you. It just has to make you look expensive.

What Separates Them

So how does a buyer tell the difference? And, more importantly for anyone reading this book, how do you make sure they tell the difference in your favor?

I have come to believe there are four things a pretender cannot easily fake. They are worth naming, because they will recur throughout this book.

The first is depth of understanding. A pretender can describe a problem. A contender can describe how the problem has changed—what used to work and no longer does, what is coming next, and what that means for this specific buyer. That kind of understanding comes from years of sitting with customers, not from a well-written prompt. It shows up in the questions you ask as much as in the answers you give.

The second is proof of delivery. Not case studies, which anyone can write, but a track record of getting customers to value predictably. How long does it really take? What goes wrong, and how is it handled? What does the customer’s experience look like in month six, not just in week one?

The third is proprietary substance. Data, content, intellectual property, domain expertise—assets that took time to build and can’t simply be generated. In a world flooded with fluent, generic content, the things only you know become disproportionately valuable.

The fourth is trust. The accumulated evidence that you keep your word. It is the hardest of the four to build and the easiest to destroy.

Notice what isn’t on that list. Features. Interface. Workflow. Speed of response. Price.

Those things matter. But they are precisely the things a pretender can copy.

Read more in Stories That Sell™

Stories That Sell™ is Paul Johns’ forthcoming book on how strategic storytelling creates competitive advantage, customer preference and enterprise value. It introduces the RO40 frameworks: Identity, the Three Question Test, the Message Map, Marketecture and Decision Confidence.

Want to put these ideas to work in your business? RO40’s Stories That Sell™ workshop brings your leadership, sales, marketing, product and customer teams together to build a story that sells. Start a conversation with RO40.

Comments


bottom of page