top of page

Becoming Your Own Undercover Boss: You'll Get What You Inspect NOT What You'll Expect

Writer: Paul Johns
Paul Johns
Oct 20, 2025
7 min read

Every company believes it understands its customers. We hold meetings about them, build strategies around them, and design GTM experiences for them. We measure our ICPs and map their “journeys,” diagram their “touch-points,” and craft detailed buyer personas with names, photos, and fictional quotes.

But if we’re honest, many of these efforts happen inside a conference room—or worse, inside our own heads. They reflect how we imagine our customer’s experience, not necessarily how it actually feels. It’s a bit like looking at an optical illusion: the picture appears clear until you tilt your head, and suddenly, what you thought was obvious looks entirely different.

That’s the danger of perspective. When you live inside your business every day, you start to believe the view from your desk is the view of the world. It isn’t.

The Optical Illusion of Understanding

Every operational workflow, every marketing campaign, every “go-to-market” discussion starts from a good place: how do we best serve our customers? Yet, when you peel back the layers, what often drives those conversations are internal realities—budgets, OKRs, departmental KPIs, board expectations, product timelines. We build systems that make sense to us, and then we assume that sense will translate to the outside world.

It rarely does.

Our customers don’t experience our businesses through our processes or our org charts. They experience us through moments—frustrating, delightful, confusing, purposeful or rewarding moments that define whether they trust us, believe us, and ultimately, buy from us.

That’s why leaders need to develop what I call undercover empathy. It’s not enough to gather customer feedback or run surveys. You need to feel what your customers feel. You need to walk through your own buying experience as a stranger, unburdened by insider knowledge, and see if you’d truly buy from yourself.

You get what you inspect, not what you expect

A great CEO I once worked with had a saying: “You get what you inspect, not what you expect.” It stuck with me. Expectations are easy. Inspection is hard.

Inspection forces you to step out of your comfort zone and into the uncomfortable reality of your own experience. When was the last time you actually tried to buy from your own company—not as yourself, but as a completely uninformed buyer?

  • Have you gone to your website and tried to find what you sell without using insider terms?

  • Have you filled out your own demo request form?

  • Have you waited to see how long it takes to get a response?

  • Have you asked for a quote, or tried to cancel, or requested help—and measured the tone and timeliness of what came back?

These moments define customer experience far more than the high-gloss language in our sales decks.

In the same way “Secret Shopping” gave retail managers a taste of what it’s like to be on the other side of the counter, modern leaders need to become undercover bosses of their own digital experiences. But here’s the twist: this isn’t just about gathering data. It’s about gathering feeling.

Because empathy, not data, is what transforms how you market and sell.

Step One: Unlearn What You Know

The first step in becoming your own undercover boss is to forget everything you know to remove any cognitive bias.

That’s harder than it sounds.

Try this thought experiment: imagine you’re a buyer, not a builder. You don’t know the internal jargon, you haven’t seen your roadmap slides, and you have no idea what your product does beyond a few headlines. You’re looking for a solution to a problem, not for your company.

Now—start where any normal person would.

Google it (Bing works too!).

Type in the kind of query your real customers might use. Maybe it’s “best tools for due diligence automation” or “how to screen third-party risk” or “how to analyze chemical pricing volatility.”

Do you appear? And if you do, what kind of story greets you? Is it clear? Helpful? Credible? Or is it generic and self-congratulatory?

Now click through a few competitors. Forget the instinct to critique. Instead, look for honesty. Which brand makes you feel understood? Which one connects with your world? Which one would you trust if you were spending your own money?

Unlearning is the hardest part because your brain will want to defend your brand. It will want to rationalize. Don’t let it. The best leaders learn to observe their own companies with brutal objectivity.

Step Two: Experience Your Own Journey

Next, trace the full journey—from initial curiosity to actual purchase—as if you were a potential customer. Think of yourself as a detective mapping evidence.

Here are some things to try:

  1. Visit your website from scratch.

  2. Follow your own CTAs.

  3. Measure the response.

  4. Ask for help.

  5. Look at your content.

  6. Try to buy.

Each of these moments is a mirror. They reflect not what you intend to deliver, but what you actually deliver. And that reflection can be sobering.

Step Three: Feel What They Feel

Most customer-experience programs stop at measurement. They produce charts and NPS dashboards and PowerPoint decks with cheerful green arrows. But customers don’t live in spreadsheets. They live in moments that make them feel something.

That’s why the real question isn’t “What’s our conversion rate?” but “What emotion are we creating?”

Here’s a useful exercise: after every step in your own buying journey, write down the emotion you felt...

  • Confused?

  • Frustrated?

  • Impressed?

  • Reassured?

  • Bored?

  • Empowered?

Patterns will appear quickly. Those emotions are your brand, more than any tagline or color palette.

If you want to build customer loyalty, you must engineer positive emotion into every stage of the experience. That doesn’t mean everything has to be cheerful—it means everything has to be clear, helpful, and human.

Step Four: Educate, Don’t Sell

One of the most powerful indicators of empathy is whether your customer leaves each interaction feeling smarter than when they arrived.

Does your thought leadership genuinely teach something?

Does it connect to your buyers’ KPIs?

Does it speak to their world with credibility and purpose?

Most B2B content fails this test. It’s inward-facing—built around what the company wants to say, not what the customer needs to learn. Great thought leadership does the opposite. It begins with the customer’s struggle and ends with a new way of thinking, even if they never buy from you.

Ask yourself:

  • Is our content useful on its own merit?

  • Does it empathize with the constraints and pressures our buyers face?

  • Does it show we understand not only the what of their job, but the why?

If the answer is no, then it’s time to stop producing content and start producing clarity.

Step Five: Redesign for Effortless Trust

The best customer experiences share a simple trait: they make people feel safe to proceed.

That safety comes from frictionless design—forms that are simple, messages that are direct, promises that are kept. But it also comes from tone. The tone of your communication says more about your culture than any mission statement.

Here’s a simple rule:

Every interaction should make the customer feel that working with you will make their life easier, not harder - take them on that journey with you.

That’s the ultimate test of empathy.

So go through your own experience again, but this time, count the clicks, the steps, the micro-frictions. How easy is it to request a demo, to talk to a human, to get value fast? How much patience does your process assume your customers have? (Because they don’t have much.)

If your brand experience feels bureaucratic, it will never feel trustworthy.

Step Six: Create Your Own “Undercover Boss” Program

This is where inspection becomes culture.

Don’t make this a one-time audit. Turn it into a living discipline across your leadership team. Assign executives to rotate as undercover buyers once a quarter. Have your sales leaders request a demo anonymously. Have your marketing team sign up for your competitors’ newsletters.

Then gather together—not to defend, but to discuss.

  • What surprised you?

  • What delighted you?

  • What disappointed you?

  • What can we fix tomorrow?

If you embed this mindset, you’ll create a company that is relentlessly curious about its own reality. That curiosity is the seed of transformation.

Step Seven: Build Empathy Into Your Metrics

Finally, don’t just measure outcomes. Measure empathy.

Here are a few practical indicators that show whether you’re truly seeing through your customers’ eyes:

  1. Response Time — How quickly do you acknowledge an inbound request, and is that acknowledgement human or automated?

  2. Ease of Evaluation — How simple is it for a prospect to understand value, access information, and make a decision without pressure?

  3. Learning Impact — After engaging with your thought leadership, do prospects feel more informed, or just more sold to?

  4. Emotional Feedback — Use open-ended questions in feedback forms: “How did this experience make you feel?” The answers will be more revealing than any score.

  5. Journey Completion Rate — How many people start but don’t finish your demo request or sign-up flow? Where do they drop off, and why?

When you measure empathy, you signal to your organization that customer understanding is not a soft skill—it’s a commercial advantage.

The Courage to See Clearly

Being your own undercover boss takes humility. You’ll find things you don’t like. You’ll see gaps between your intentions and your reality. You might even feel embarrassed by how difficult it is to buy from you.

Good. That’s the point.

Because the moment you can see those gaps, you can close them. The moment you feel what your customers feel, you can change it. The moment you reconnect with what it’s like to be on the outside looking in, you rediscover what empathy really means.

And empathy, at its core, is the most powerful driver of growth there is.

Customers don’t stay loyal because you’re perfect. They stay loyal because you understand them. Because you make them feel seen, heard, and valued. Because you’ve taken the time to inspect what they experience—not to judge them, but to improve yourself.

The Takeaway

So here’s a simple challenge for the week ahead:

  • Go to your own website like a stranger.

  • Try to buy from yourself.

  • Try to get help.

  • Try to learn.

  • Try to cancel.

  • And along the way, write down how each moment makes you feel.

If you can’t describe your own experience as educational, easy, and efficient, then neither can your customers.

Being an undercover boss isn’t about catching people out—it’s about catching yourself out. It’s about rediscovering your business through the eyes of the only person who really matters: the one deciding whether or not to trust you with their time, their data, and their money.

Final Thought

Every business has blind spots. Every leader falls into the comfort of internal logic. But the companies that win—truly win—are those willing to inspect themselves with curiosity and courage.

So take off the executive badge for a day.

Step into the shoes of a customer.

See what they see. Feel what they feel.

You might just find that the most powerful growth strategy you’ll ever deploy is empathy—in action, not in theory.

Originally published by Paul Johns on LinkedIn.

Comments


bottom of page