top of page

The New Give to Get to win new logos

Writer: Paul Johns
Paul Johns
Aug 24
10 min read

A few weeks ago, I walked into Sunglass Hut with two pairs of sunglasses that needed fixing. Only one pair had actually been bought there, and I expected that distinction to matter. It didn’t. Nobody asked me to prove where I had bought them, nobody checked a receipt and nobody tried to establish whether I was technically entitled to their help. They simply took both pairs, fixed them, cleaned them and, in the case of one pair, spent some time reshaping the frames so they fitted properly again. There was no charge, no sales pitch and no obvious expectation of anything in return.

What made the experience more interesting is that this wasn’t the first time they had done it. It was the third. Somewhere across those three relatively insignificant interactions, something quite significant had happened to my relationship with Sunglass Hut. I found myself buying more from them, but perhaps more importantly, I found myself selling for them. A friend of mine needed a pair of sunglasses repaired recently and I didn’t give her a list of places she could try. I told her she had to go to Sunglass Hut in London. She did, they repaired her glasses, and shortly afterwards she sent me a photograph of the new pair she had bought while she was there.

There is something wonderfully simple about that customer journey because nobody actually tried to convert anybody. There was no carefully constructed nurture sequence, no gated content, no ROI calculator and no particularly obvious call to action. Sunglass Hut simply created an experience that was disproportionately valuable compared with what they asked for in return. That experience created trust, trust created preference and, eventually, preference created revenue. Not only from me, but from somebody else I had effectively introduced to the brand.

I had a completely different version of the same experience recently. Someone introduced me to a television series on a streaming service I didn’t subscribe to. Like most people, I already feel as though I have enough streaming subscriptions. There comes a point where you look at all those relatively small monthly charges and wonder quite how many different platforms one household actually needs, so the last thing I wanted was another one.

The streaming company could have given me a trailer. They could have unlocked the first episode, or offered me a seven-day free trial and asked for my credit card details before I had really experienced anything. Instead, they gave me the whole of season one. So I watched an episode, then another, and then another. Very quickly, I wasn’t evaluating a streaming service anymore. I was invested in a story. I knew the characters, I cared about what happened to them and I had experienced the quality of the product without having to make a decision about buying the product.

Then, as all great seasons tend to do, season one ended with a cliffhanger. Suddenly the entire commercial dynamic had changed. They didn’t need to convince me to subscribe anymore. I needed them to let me continue. I signed up because I wanted season two and season three.

That, to me, is the new give-to-get.

For years, particularly in B2B marketing, we have operated around a fairly conservative exchange of value. Give us your email address and we’ll give you a white paper. Give us your details and we’ll let you watch the webinar. Give us thirty minutes and we’ll give you a demo. Tell us enough about your business and we’ll produce an ROI calculation designed to demonstrate why you should buy from us. It is an exchange model that has become so familiar that we rarely stop to question whether it still reflects the way people actually want to buy.

Increasingly, I don’t think it does. People don’t simply want more information before they buy. They want more evidence. They want to understand more, evaluate more and experience more. They want to see behind the curtain and understand how a company thinks, how it behaves, what it really knows and what they are actually going to get when the relationship moves from prospect to customer. Most importantly, they increasingly want to experience the value you provide rather than listen to you describe the value you provide.

We have spent decades building marketing around the promise of value. I think the next era of marketing will increasingly be built around the experience of value.

And nowhere is that shift more interesting than in businesses whose product is, in one form or another, content, information, data, analysis or expertise.

We are entering an extraordinary paradox. There has never been more content in the world, and genuinely valuable content may never have been more valuable. Generative AI has made the creation of competent content almost frictionless. In seconds we can create an article, a report, a summary, an explanation, a point of view or a hundred variations of essentially the same idea. The internet was already noisy. AI is turning that noise into something closer to a roar.

But abundance does not necessarily create value. Often it does precisely the opposite. When everybody can create something that looks like expertise, knowing where genuine expertise came from becomes more important. When everybody can produce an answer, confidence in the answer becomes more valuable. When enormous quantities of content can be generated from essentially the same publicly available information, proprietary insight, original research, trusted data, specialist analysis and human judgement become increasingly distinctive.

This creates a fascinating challenge for professional information and content businesses because these companies spend significant amounts of money creating things that are genuinely difficult to create. They employ journalists, analysts, economists, lawyers, researchers, subject-matter experts and data scientists. They collect proprietary information, validate data, establish benchmarks, develop methodologies and build specialist expertise over decades. They create content where somebody is prepared to stand behind the answer. That is fundamentally different from simply generating more words.

And yet many of these businesses are still applying an old philosophy to a completely new information economy. They protect their most valuable material because, historically, that has seemed like the commercially responsible thing to do. The best analysis sits behind the paywall. The premium report requires registration. The proprietary data is invisible until somebody becomes a customer. The deeper expertise only appears once the sales process has progressed far enough to justify revealing it.

The logic is understandable. If something costs millions to create, why would you give it away?

But the new give-to-get dynamic complicates that question, because if everything that demonstrates your true authority is hidden, how is a prospective customer supposed to understand why your content is different from the ocean of information they can now access for free?

That question becomes much more important in an AI world. The public-facing experience of a sophisticated information company cannot simply consist of generic articles, promotional copy and locked doors while all the extraordinary intelligence remains hidden somewhere behind them. If that happens, the prospect may never get close enough to understand what makes the business exceptional. Worse still, the comparison is no longer simply between your free content and another professional provider’s free content. It is between your free content and an effectively infinite supply of AI-generated answers.

That fundamentally changes the economics of gating.

The answer obviously isn’t to tear down the paywall. If a business invests millions creating proprietary intelligence, trusted journalism, specialist analysis or unique data, giving all of it away would make no commercial sense. But equally, protecting all of it may increasingly make no marketing sense. The question is no longer simply, “What should be gated and what should be ungated?” The much more interesting question is, “What does somebody need to experience for free in order to understand why they should pay for more?”

That distinction is important because it turns gating from a lead-generation tactic into an experience-design decision.

For years, we have often treated ungated content as the cheaper version of the real thing. The introductory article. The lightweight summary. The generic thought-leadership piece designed to attract a search engine rather than genuinely change somebody’s thinking. Then, once we have captured enough information about the person, we begin revealing the better material.

I think that model has to change. In a world drowning in average content, the free experience cannot simply be more average content. In some respects, what we give away needs to be some of the best material we have because it is doing an entirely different job. Its purpose is not to satisfy the entire need. Its purpose is to demonstrate the extraordinary quality of what sits behind it.

That brings me back to the streaming service. They didn’t give me the worst episode for free. They gave me season one. They gave me enough quality, enough story and enough value to become invested, but they also understood exactly where the experience should stop. That is a useful metaphor for any professional content business. Perhaps the future isn’t about giving away the cheap stuff and charging for the good stuff. Perhaps it is about giving away enough of the good stuff that people understand why the rest is worth paying for.

Imagine a professional information company with a remarkable piece of proprietary research. The traditional approach might be to put the entire report behind a registration form or subscription wall. The new give-to-get approach might expose the most provocative finding, show some of the underlying data and allow somebody to explore part of the analysis. It might provide enough expert interpretation to fundamentally change the reader’s understanding of the issue, and then it stops.

Not arbitrarily. It stops at the point where curiosity becomes consequence.

The reader now knows something they didn’t know before, but more importantly, they understand that there is more they need to know. They have moved from casually consuming content to recognising that the answer could materially affect a decision they have to make. That is the cliffhanger.

For a streaming company, the cliffhanger is what happens to the character next. For a professional information company, the cliffhanger is what happens to me next. What happens to my market, my price, my regulatory exposure, my supply chain, my workforce, my competitors or the value of my assets? What happens if the scenario described in this analysis actually occurs, and what should I do about it?

Those are commercially powerful questions because they move the reader beyond simply consuming content and create a need for continued intelligence. And that distinction between content and intelligence is going to become increasingly important.

AI can create extraordinary quantities of content. What businesses making high-value decisions actually need is confidence. They need to know where the information came from, how it was created, what methodology sits behind it and whether it can be trusted. They need context and interpretation. They need to understand what has changed, why it matters and what might happen next. Ultimately, they need somebody prepared to stand behind the answer.

In a world of infinite information, provenance becomes a premium product and trust becomes part of the value proposition.

That means professional content businesses should not be trying to compete with AI on volume. That is a race they cannot and should not try to win. They should compete on authority. But authority cannot remain an abstract marketing claim. Authority has to be experienced.

This is why I believe the prospect journey and the customer journey increasingly need to move closer together. We need to allow prospects to experience some of the things that historically only customers experienced. Not promotional descriptions of the intelligence, but some of the intelligence itself. Not claims about expertise, but actual expertise. Not screenshots of proprietary data, but opportunities to interact with enough meaningful data to discover something. Not statements about trust, but visible provenance, methodology and evidence.

Bring people under the hood.

Let them see why something took ten analysts rather than ten seconds. Let them see the research behind the conclusion, the specialist judgement behind the interpretation and the proprietary data behind the answer. Let them understand what an expert sees that a generic answer simply cannot.

Then give them enough of that experience that returning to the free alternative begins to feel like a compromise.

Because that is the second and perhaps most powerful half of the give-to-get equation. The best free experiences don’t simply demonstrate the pleasure of becoming a customer. They begin to expose the pain of not becoming one.

Before I watched season one, I was perfectly comfortable not subscribing. I wasn’t walking around feeling that something was missing from my life. Then I watched it, became invested and suddenly understood exactly what I was losing by remaining outside. Nothing about the paid product had changed. What had changed was my understanding of its value.

The same should be true of high-value B2B content. Before somebody experiences your intelligence, they may be perfectly happy searching Google, asking an AI assistant, reading industry news or piecing together an answer themselves. Your job is not simply to tell them that your intelligence is better. Your job is to allow them to experience the difference.

Show them something they couldn’t easily find elsewhere. Give them an insight they couldn’t easily create themselves. Reveal a risk they hadn’t considered. Provide context they didn’t know they were missing. Suddenly the free alternative still exists, but it no longer feels equivalent. You have changed their understanding of what good looks like.

That is a very different form of demand generation.

It means we need to stop thinking about gating purely as a mechanism for capturing leads and start thinking about it as part of the architecture of the customer experience. Instead of asking, “How quickly can we get their email address?”, perhaps we should be asking, “How far into our value can we take them before they desperately want the next chapter?”

That requires confidence. You have to believe that exposing your best thinking increases its value rather than diminishes it. You have to believe that expertise becomes more commercially powerful when somebody experiences it. And you have to accept that somebody may consume something genuinely valuable today without immediately giving you anything in return.

The get may come later.

Sometimes the person whose sunglasses you repair buys another pair six months later. Sometimes they tell a friend who walks into your store for a repair and walks out with a new pair. Sometimes the executive who reads an extraordinary piece of analysis today doesn’t fill in a form, become an MQL or request a demo. But perhaps that analysis changes the way they understand their market. Perhaps three months later something happens and they remember who helped them see it coming. At that moment, the distinction between free content and trusted intelligence becomes incredibly clear.

We have become incredibly sophisticated at measuring the immediate exchange of value. We are considerably less sophisticated at understanding the accumulated commercial value of simply being useful. In the age of AI, I think that may become one of the most important changes marketing has to make.

Because when content itself becomes infinite, the scarce commodity is no longer information. It is confidence in the information. It is provenance, authority and trust.

The great content businesses of the next decade will understand that protecting those things does not necessarily mean hiding them. Sometimes the best way to protect the commercial value of expertise is to let people experience enough of it to understand just how valuable it really is.

Bring the prospect under the hood. Show them the difference between generated information and trusted intelligence. Give them enough of the story to become invested and enough of the experience to change their expectations. Then understand exactly where to create the cliffhanger.

Because the new give-to-get isn’t about giving everything away.

It is about giving enough that going without the rest begins to feel like the greater cost.

Originally published by Paul Johns on LinkedIn.

Comments


bottom of page